American Idol vs. American Democracy: Why the Votes Don’t Compare

On May 18, 2025, Jamal Roberts—a 27-year-old P.E. teacher and father of three from Meridian, Mississippi—was crowned the winner of American Idol Season 23.  His victory was powered by a record-breaking 26 million votes, the highest since the show's move to ABC in 2018.

In the aftermath, social media buzzed with comparisons between the ease of voting for American Idol and the complexities of participating in U.S. elections.  Some criticized those who cast multiple votes for their favorite singer but abstained from local, state, or federal elections.  However, equating these two voting processes overlooks significant differences in accessibility, eligibility, and systemic barriers. 

Voting: Entertainment vs. Civic Duty

1. Accessibility

American Idol: Voting is open to anyone aged 13 or older in the U.S., Puerto Rico, or the U.S. Virgin Islands.  Fans can cast up to 10 votes per contestant through each of three methods: online, via the American Idol app, and by text message—totaling up to 30 votes per contestant  .

U.S. Elections: Voting requires U.S. citizenship, registration by a state-specific deadline, and being at least 18 years old on or before Election Day.  Additionally, some states impose restrictions on individuals with felony convictions, and voter ID laws vary, potentially creating further obstacles  .

2. Eligibility

American Idol: No citizenship or legal residency requirements exist.  Anyone meeting the age and location criteria can participate, regardless of legal status or criminal history. 

U.S. Elections: Non-citizens, including permanent legal residents, are prohibited from voting in federal, state, and most local elections.  Individuals with certain felony convictions may also be disenfranchised, depending on state laws  .

3. Voting Process

American Idol: Voting is designed to be quick and user-friendly, often taking just seconds per vote.  Multiple votes are encouraged, allowing fans to have a significant impact on the outcome. 

U.S. Elections: The process can be time-consuming and complex, involving registration, understanding ballot measures, and potentially facing long lines or limited polling hours.  Each eligible voter is allowed only one vote per election, emphasizing the principle of "one person, one vote." 

The Bigger Picture

Criticizing individuals for participating in entertainment voting but not in civic elections ignores the systemic barriers that many face in the electoral process.  Factors such as voter suppression, disenfranchisement, and lack of access to voting resources disproportionately affect marginalized communities. 

Instead of shaming, we should focus on making the democratic process more accessible and inclusive.  This includes advocating for policies that expand voting rights, simplify registration, and educate citizens about the importance of their vote. 

Conclusion

While both American Idol and U.S. elections involve voting, the similarities end there.  Understanding the distinctions between these processes is crucial in fostering a more informed and engaged electorate.  By addressing the systemic challenges within our democratic system, we can work towards a society where every citizen has an equal opportunity to have their voice heard.  

Reflection Questions:

1. What emotional or mental barriers keep me from fully participating in democracy?

2. What power do I have in my community through my vote—and how am I using or neglecting it?

3. What is one step I can take today to become more engaged in my local or national political process?

Cynthia Young

Certified Spiritual Care Life Coach 

Follow me on Facebook or LinkedIn. Check out my Website.